OVRMMO16: Extra: How Recipes Work

Translator note:
Uwaah, I wasn’t expecting readers so soon so I put up Chapter 15 without proofreading, intending to go back and edit later … typos galore! How embarrassing. (〃艸〃)
So uh, hi, and thanks for all your comments!
Also, thanks to readers’-proofing, I’ve corrected a confusing mis-trans in Chap14:
“Thanks to [Stealth]’s concealment the Wild Bear won’t figure out where the arrow came from even if he’s hit with it”, it should be “figure out the arrow’s coming until he’s hit with it.” Classic case of assuming the content instead of reading it. -_-;

The VRMMO Activities of a Certain Old Man
Author: Shiina Howahowa

Extra: How Recipes Work.

 That day it started with one statement.

“Lately haven’t the number of people taking [Cooking] increased? I’d like to learn some dishes myself, but you gotta pay to get Recipes, right?”

That was Nora’s one statement.

Reiji and Nora, who came to buy food from me, let that statement out while stuffing their cheeks.
I put on a stern expression.

“Aaa~… buying Recipes is just about impossible, they aren’t really sold.
The reason is kinda long. This isn’t just my policy, it’s how all the crafters have been dealing with it.

That was my explanation, but…

“Now I’m interested. Mind going into the details?”

Reiji said, curious.
Since it really IS a long explanation I gave them White-Peach flavored Potion Juice before I began.


There’s an unspoken agreement among the current Crafting Skill players about not selling Recipes.
There are two reasons for it, and the first is a story about the money involved.

The time and money to develop one Recipe is pretty hefty.
As an example, let’s say a Recipe is a completed 50 piece Jigsaw puzzle.
The thing is, you have 10,000 pieces to look through.
That’s the kind of process it is.

Since that’s the kind of process it is, a LOT of funding is absolutely necessary to find the correct 50 pieces.
This is the same for all Crafting Skills.
Even I’ve sunk a lot of money into creating new dishes, but if it weren’t for this long explanation of mine no one would be able to tell.

Also, in regards to profit, Horned Rabbit with Water Herbs is terrific, but since the meat is tough you need Salt at 10Glow, Mixed Spice at 20Glow, Herb at 10Glow; it takes at least this much money.
In addition if it’s not a 7 or higher quality and it’s not cheap, there’s no way you can rake in the sales.
Right now I can gather Herbs to cover what I make, but for the times when the demand is too much I have to buy it from the NPC.

The net profit I’m making at this point is reduced to about 60Glow for every new dish I come up with, and even the profit disappears into further research and development for improvements.
If you want to make money, just going hunting is much more profitable.
The only way I could afford the Werewolf Leather Set I have equipped now was to stop spending money on Recipe research until I somehow got 86,000Glow.

Now, this down-and-dirty behind the scenes coverage of the reason why Recipes aren’t being sold had two parts. This second one is much deeper.

There’s a huge possibility that there’s a hidden stat to go along with Crafting Skill Level.

This isn’t just my belief. When a large group of Crafters came together to discuss Recipes, I heard a story about a Weaponsmith.

That Weaponsmith was pretty skilled. The Great Swords he sold were consistently an 8 in Quality.
The world of Quality difference is cruel.
Let’s say a Quality 5 Great Sword has an attack power of 100.
At Quality 6 it’s 110, at Quality 7 it jumps to 130.
At Quality 8 it’s 160, incomparable to the others. (For Cooking it’s the taste that improves.)
Because of that, lots of swordsmen would look to get their weapons from that Weaponsmith.
After all, strong equipment will protect you and you can hunt more efficiently to earn money quicker.

There was a player who saw his thriving business.
That player thought that if he could get his hands on that Great Sword Recipe, there was easy money to be made.

So, with a large amount of money he bought the Recipe from the Weaponsmith.

After that he gathered all the materials required and hammered iron like mad, mass-producing Great Swords according to the Recipe
Of course his [Weaponsmithing] level skyrocketed in no time.

Now then, if they were Quality 7 or 8 Great Swords there wouldn’t be a problem.
Instead, it didn’t matter how many swords he made or how much his skill level increased;
no matter how much he hammered away, he never got anything other than Quality 5 Great Swords.

That player was convinced that the Weaponsmith cheated him with a fake Recipe.
It seems he stormed in and demanded that his money be returned.

It became a huge fight and, seeing no end to it, they decided that the Weaponsmith who developed the Recipe would make it according the Recipe he had written while in front of several Crafter witnesses.
In front of both the witnesses and the player who had bought the Recipe, he made one Great Sword.
Immediately after he finished, the Great Sword was handed over to the witnesses.
This was to ensure that the sword the Weaponsmith made wasn’t switched for another.

The result was a Great Sword with a Quality of a stunning value of 9.
Just like the Recipe, with the same materials and the same forging methods, a gem of a sword came into being right before their eyes.
This was definite proof that the Weaponsmith who sold the Recipe committed no fraud.

From these results, as far as Crafting Skill level is concerned it only lets you make the item.
To improve the Quality there’s gotta be a hidden stat…
That was the rumor that was quickly spread.

More importantly, this suggests that there’s more than one way to make something.

As more people take [Cooking] there may be more and more players who will make Horned Rabbit meat dishes, but with stuffed cabbage, soup, grilled skewers, stewed dishes – there are actually tons of variations to try.
They may take different flavors, they may take different forms, but all of them are products that have been perfected.

In the game, actually there’s not just 1 possibility for a Recipe.
For weapons, for armor, there are many different ways to make them, and all of those ways are “correct”.
It’s definitely a tough task to find 50 pieces that fit together from 10,000.
‘Cause there’s a ton of “right answers”

So, going back to that Weaponsmith’s story and that Great Sword he made, another weaponsmith’s forging method and Recipe are, for the most part, different.
Even if the materials used are the same, there are many ways to make something, and all the ways are different.
And all the ways are “correct”, see?
However you look at it, between finished items of the same Quality, neither is inferior.

All the Crafters who had gathered decided that this was, without a doubt, how things worked.
They concluded that a Recipe is the crystallization of a person’s hard work and ingenuity.
When imitating that person’s Recipe, it’s impossible to reach the original’s Quality.

For that reason, selling a Recipe to someone could actually prevent their growth as Crafter.
To avoid that, it was decided not to sell Recipes.
This explanation and the one on the Info Site is long, but there’ve been people who don’t believe us and try to call us out, saying, “Crafters are making this up to keep others out of the profits.”

“So, with that really long explanation, that’s why I don’t teach other people my Recipes.
I’ll teach the basics, though. From there it’s best if you go and work your own puzzle to completion.”

And now that the explanation is over, the two who were listening while drinking Potion Juice…

“Hee… so there was a story like that, huh~ … so that Info Site’s article wasn’t just a bunch of people trying to monopolize the Recipes.”

That’s what Nora muttered absentmindedly.

“Weell, it can’t be helped that you took it that way but … the truth is the truth, ya know?”

There’s always people who don’t believe the truth even in real life.
Well, I don’t want to bring real life into the game world.
With just age as a factor there’s a lot of things you can’t do, things impossible for you and things decided for you, for example.
That’s not really fun, and a little sad, right?
Try it just to try it, if it doesn’t work then look around for another way.
That’s the way I like to game.

There’s no Skill Writeup in this extra.
This is the feel of how this world’s Crafting and Recipes work.

<Previous Chapter]   [Index]   [Next Chapter>



    1. lol, it said it would take at least 24 hours to be approved … I thought I had time!!! 😀
      … or maybe i thought it said “at least”…


      1. I meant the part about most of his profits going into funding for new recipes and how he supplemented it with manually gathering herbs. I just realized how misleading saying ‘backstory’ was. My bad.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s